For immediate release:
February 25, 2005

Barrett reveals lack of government preparedness for bird flu concerns

UN, Barrett pandemic warnings fall on deaf ears

Queen’s Park – Months after being accused of fearmongering by the Minister of Agriculture, Haldimand-Norfolk-Brant MPP Toby Barrett again questioned the government’s preparedness to deal with international warnings of a potential bird flu pandemic.

With the Agriculture Minister absent, Barrett directed his question to the Acting Premier and Minister of Health George Smitherman.

“On April 15 last year, a day after I asked what the government's plans were for H5N1, your minister said, ‘I think it is very unfortunate that we are fearmongering in this province,’” Barrett recounted. “You know this file. Do you feel that asking questions about bird flu is fearmongering?”

Minister Smitherman responded by indicating the government is listening and learning – but made no mention of any concrete plan of action.

“What I do know on this very important subject is that the Ministry of Health and the Ministry of Agriculture have been working very closely with a variety of interested people,” said Smitherman. “We have, of course, been taking lessons that have been applied through the work of Health Canada, and working very closely with the World Health Organization with a view to learning all the lessons that can be learned.”

Barrett went back at the Minister, pointing out that international officials are now warning of a possible pandemic and asking for a plan to prepare for the potential disaster-in-waiting.

Barrett quoted the experts:

“Dr. Julie Gerberding, the head of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, is now saying scientists expect Asian bird flu virus will change into a flu that can be transmitted between humans - she considers this "a very high threat," and Hans Wagner, of the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization: "At the moment, we are not on top of it."

“What steps are being taken to prevent an outbreak of H5N1?” Barrett asked. “Is your Minister of Agriculture or your Minister of the Environment listening to their staff? Is there a plan?”

In his response Smitherman referred to a plan, but failed to produce any details.


-30-
For more information please contact MPP Toby Barrett at: 519-428-0446, 416-325-8404 or 1-800-903-8629